Skip to content
Baltic Dry1,942+1.84% SCFI1,388.6-2.10% WCI 40ft$2,214-1.35% Brent$74.18+0.62% VLSFO SG$548.5+0.40% Harpex2,2310.00% USD/BRL5.412-0.28% EUR/USD1.0864+0.11%
Tuesday
November 17, 2026
The Port Journal

SCOTUS action revives shipper/receiver liability post-Montgomery

A decision handed down by the U.S. Supreme Court Monday is setting up the possibility of a major decision on the question of shipper and recipient liability in a post-Montgomery world. The high court…

1 min read

A decision handed down by the U.S. Supreme Court Monday is setting up the possibility of a major decision on the question of shipper and recipient liability in a post-Montgomery world.

The high court granted certiorari in the case of Casarez vs. Irigoyen Farms et. al. in an action known as a Grant, Vacate, Remand Order (GVR). Unlike a more traditional certiorari finding, a granting of GVR allows the high court to send the case back to a lower court without actually ruling on its merits, but keeping open a chance the nine justices will take up the issue later.

With its GVR order, the case of Casarez vs. Irigoyen Farms will be returned to a California appellate court that will take up anew the question of whether a shipper or even their customer can be hit with liability coming out of a crash. The legal process in Casarez so far has firmly answered “no” to that question.

But that was before Montgomery vs. Caribe Transport II stripped away certain protections for brokers, with the possibility that the new landscape for litigation could eventually create liability for shippers–and their customers–as well.

This story was originally published by FreightWaves. Read the full story at FreightWaves →

Conversation

Comments are moderated before publication.

More in Road Freight

View all
BACK TO TOP ▲